Biocontainment of Genetically Engineered Algae, an Update

Seagriculture USA 2024
Genetic Biocontainment

Genetic biocontainment strategies are under development to reduce the probability that these engineered organisms can survive outside of the laboratory or industrial setting. Credit: greenleaf123

by Jacob Sebesta, Wei Xiong, Michael T. Guarieri and Jianping Yu, Biosciences Center, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO

At industrial scale, genetically engineered algae may be cultivated outdoors in open ponds or in closed photobioreactors. In either case, industry would need to address a potential risk of the release of the engineered algae into the natural environment, resulting in potential negative impacts to the environment. Genetic biocontainment strategies are therefore under development to reduce the probability that these engineered organisms can survive outside of the laboratory or industrial setting.

These strategies intend to kill the escaped cells by expression of toxic proteins, and passive strategies that use knockouts of native genes to reduce fitness outside of the controlled environment of labs and industrial cultivation systems.

Several biocontainment strategies have demonstrated escape frequencies below detection limits. However, they have typically done so in carefully controlled experiments which may fail to capture mechanisms of escape that may arise in the more complex natural environment. The selection of biocontainment strategies that can effectively kill cells outside the lab, while maintaining maximum productivity inside the lab and without the need for relatively expensive chemicals needs further study.

Introduction to this research

Genetic modification of algae, including eukaryotic microalgae and cyanobacteria, is expected to facilitate direct conversion of light energy and inorganic carbon to a wide variety of valuable chemicals. As with other genetically modified organisms (GMOs), the environmental risk of large-scale cultivation must be assessed, and appropriate measures must be taken to mitigate those risks. Previously, Henley et al. (2013) reported a risk assessment for genetically engineered microalgae, finding that risks to human health, the environment, and the economy, were generally low, but not zero.

Given that genetically engineered algae may be grown outdoors, possibly in open ponds, they determined that the potential for these cells to escape into the environment is elevated beyond that of typical industrial microbial cultivation. Therefore, they recommended the development of biocontainment strategies which reduce growth fitness in the natural environment, that are conditionally lethal to the cells when they are not in the lab or industrial setting and that have reduced capability to transfer genetic material to other organisms.

Since that report, many new genetic biocontainment strategies have been developed for microalgae and other industrially relevant microorganisms which achieve one or more of those goals.

In synthetic auxotrophy, cells are modified to make their growth dependent on an unusual or nonnatural nutrient or an unnaturally high concentration of a nutrient. Examples include dependence on unusual phosphorous sources like phosphite and dependence on high concentrations of carbon dioxide.

Further efforts have been made to express toxic proteins, such as nucleases, in the cells in a manner dependent on the conditions outside the lab, typically, the loss of some synthetic signal molecule or an unnatural concentration of a signal molecule. Biocontainment strategies have been collected in the Biocontainment Finder on the Standardsinsynbio.eu website.

The full version of this review summarizes the rationale for designing genetically encoded biocontainment systems and the efforts made thus far to assess their efficacy in genetically engineered algae. First, the report discusses the possible escape routes and fates of escaped algae. The regulatory requirements for outdoor cultivation of genetically engineered algae in a few regions are then summarized. Next, an overview of the different types of genetically encoded biocontainment strategies that may be used in algae is provided.

An examination of whether lab tests, which frequently demonstrate the achievement of meeting the NIH guideline of a 10−8 cell survival rate, are truly representative of what may occur if cultures were released into the natural environment. And finally, there is a discussion on the results of some specific examples of genetically encoded biocontainment found in recent publications and some suggestions for future directions.

All rights reserved. Permission required to reprint articles in their entirety. Must include copyright statement and live hyperlinks. Contact david@algaeplanet.com. Algae Planet accepts unsolicited manuscripts for consideration, and takes no responsibility for the validity of claims made in submitted editorial.

Seagriculture USA 2024
AlgaeMetrics
Contact Phil Ganz

Subscribe

Breaking-News

  • July 19, 2024: A three-year development effort, the Ethiopian Bio and Emerging Technology Institute — in collaboration with the Ministry of Innovation and Technology and the Oromia Agricultural Research Institute — has recently launched the nation’s first microalgae (spirulina) research and production center at the Adami Tulu Agriculture Center, from an investment of 8.2 million birr ($142,600 USD). READ MORE...
  • July 17, 2024: A study from the University of New Hampshire has found that integrating farmed shrimp with oysters and seaweed in integrated multi-trophic aquaculture (IMTA) systems significantly reduces nitrogen levels. This could make shrimp farming more responsible and potentially support the growth of the U.S. industry. READ MORE...
  • July 15, 2024: Atlantic Sea Farms, a Maine-based leader in farmed seaweed, has harvested a record-breaking 1.3 million pounds of farmed seaweed in the 2024 harvest season. The company, which partners with fishing families to farm kelp in Maine, Rhode Island, and Alaska, has expanded both the supply of domestic line-grown kelp, as well as the market for their traceable, regeneratively farmed products to American consumers, chefs, and CPG companies since 2019. READ MORE...
  • July 12, 2024: Researchers have created tiny, vehicle-like structures which can be maneuvered by microscopic algae. The algae are caught in baskets attached to the micromachines, which have been carefully designed to allow them enough room to continue swimming. Two types of vehicles were created: the “rotator,” which spins like a wheel, and the “scooter,” which was intended to move in a forward direction but in tests moved more surprisingly. READ MORE...

Algae Europe 2024

A Beginner’s Guide